"If appraised values go down, our tax rate goes up," Colleyville finance director Cassie Smith told the City Council in August, as the Fort Worth Report recounted. "If our appraised values go up, tax rate goes down. Lovely seesaw effect."
That seesaw explains the city's new rate. In Colleyville this fall, the appraisal roll and the sales market went in different directions. The roll got smaller, while sale prices per square foot held steady or edged up. The next residential reappraisal in Tarrant County is already scheduled.
The Tarrant Appraisal District valued Colleyville's 2026 tax roll at $8.9 billion, down 3.09%. Residential values fell 3.52% to $7.8 billion, while commercial values rose 0.17% to $1.081 billion. The city's average single-family taxable value dropped from $705,492 to $678,440.
When the base shrinks and the city wants the same revenue, the rate has to rise. On Sept. 15 the council adopted $0.352480 per $100 of valuation for fiscal 2026-27, up from $0.311931. Community Impact reported that this is the third straight year the rate has gone up. The adopted figure was the highest rate the council could set without asking voters.
Here's how the city rate has moved over the past five fiscal years, combining the operations component with the debt component:
| Fiscal year | Operations | Debt service | Total per $100 |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2022-23 | $0.2650 | $0.0095 | $0.2745 |
| 2023-24 | $0.2513 | $0.0095 | $0.2608 |
| 2024-25 | $0.2601 | $0.0160 | $0.2761 |
| 2025-26 | $0.2942 | $0.0177 | $0.3119 |
| 2026-27 | $0.31865 | $0.03383 | $0.35248 |
The debt line nearly doubled this year. Smith said the higher interest-and-sinking rate covers an additional $766,000 in debt payments for the recreation center project and the fire apparatus payment schedule. According to the city's adopted budget, the city tax bill on the average-valued home rises from $2,200.65 to $2,391.37, an increase of $190.72. That happens even though the home's taxable value went down. Mayor Bobby Lindamood put it in monthly terms, telling the council, "For $20 a month for those who have to pay it, I think that's a pretty good deal."
City staff gave several reasons for the lower valuations. One was TAD's policy of reappraising residential property every two years instead of every year. Another was a rise in protests, arbitration and litigation, each of which takes value off the roll. Separately from the drop in appraisals, staff also listed growth in senior property tax exemptions among the pressures on the 2027 rate.
The two-year cycle matters most. Under TAD's 2025-2026 reappraisal plan, residential values for 2025 were held at their 2024 final values, except for new construction and new improvements. Residential reappraisals run in odd-numbered years starting in 2027. The Fort Worth Report described homes countywide as frozen at their 2024 values under that plan. Owners pushed back in large numbers: more than 272,000 Tarrant County homeowners protested in 2026.
So Colleyville's 3.52% residential decline is an appraisal-roll result. Market values weren't freshly reappraised, and protests, arbitration and litigation reduced the taxable base. The MLS figures over the same months show prices holding:
Price per square foot and supply barely moved. What did move in September was leverage. Homes sold for 93.5% of list price, down from 96.6% in September 2025, and averaged 75 days on market versus 44. Closed sales fell to 19 from 28. The September median fell to $800,000 from $1,000,000, while the average sale price dipped more modestly, to $1,052,158 from $1,092,348. With 19 closings, a couple of sales at either end can swing the median a long way. These MetroTex figures, compiled by the Texas Real Estate Research Center at Texas A&M from NTREIS data, exclude builder sales.
Countywide, TAD's chief appraiser said the market value of "probably about 190,000" homes would likely have fallen if TAD had reappraised in 2026. He added that a lower market value doesn't necessarily mean a lower appraised value, because the homestead cap already limits many appraised values. In a city where a typical September sale was around $1 million, the gap between a long-held capped value and a recent purchase price can be wide.
TAD's 2027-2028 reappraisal plan, approved Sept. 8, 2026, keeps residential reappraisals in odd-numbered years beginning in 2027 and describes countywide market trends as flat.
The city rate is the piece that changed most this year, but it isn't the largest. Grapevine-Colleyville ISD kept its rate unchanged at $0.8686 per $100. Tarrant County lowered its rate slightly, to $0.1860 from $0.1862, according to the Fort Worth Report. The county hospital district and Tarrant County College also levy their own rates. Water and sewer costs went up as well: new base charges that took effect Oct. 1 add $5.07 a month to the average residential bill.
For a rough sense of scale, the city, school district and county rates alone add up to about $1.41 per $100 before exemptions. That's a little over $14,000 a year on $1 million of taxable value, before the hospital and college lines. The exact figure depends on the value TAD assigns and the exemptions you qualify for.
Did Colleyville home prices fall in 2026? The appraisal roll fell, with residential values down 3.52%. Sale prices per square foot did not: the September 2026 city median was $275.39, compared with $270.92 a year earlier. What softened in September was speed and negotiating room, with longer days on market and a lower share of list price.
Will Colleyville's rate keep rising? The council sets the rate each year based on the roll it receives. A roll that grows after reappraisal lowers the rate needed to raise the same revenue, which is the seesaw Smith described.
This post is general information about how Texas property tax rules and Colleyville's adopted rates work, not legal, tax or financial advice. Please confirm your own situation with TAD, a tax professional or your lender.
If you're comparing Colleyville homes, Trisha Atwood can help. Let's Connect.
Stay up to date on the latest real estate trends.
What To Know Before Buying A Home In Southlake’s Golf Community.
Smart Steps To Simplify Your Space Without Giving Up Your Lifestyle.
How To Handle An Estate Sale In Southlake With Confidence And Care.
How to Experience Southlake Town Square Like a Local.